Brilliant Songs #27: Joanna Newsom’s “Baby Birch”

Sometimes, all we want and need is a short declarative bellow hooked into something hummable and danceable.

“I wanna hold your ha-aa-aa-a-anddd!”

“I can’t get noooo….satisfack-shun!”

“I seeee the ba-ad moon a-risin’!”

Other times, we slow the pace, lower the volume and still ourselves for a close listen to a story as it unspools from the mind and imagination of a singing poet as she frames a multi-layered tale across time, space and memory.

Her songs consistently beg big questions but just as consistently refuse the beggar, short-circuiting our Need to Know…

At 40 years old, the nearly unclassifiable Joanna Newsom has been telling such tales for two decades now as a singer-songwriter and harpist. (Yes, the harp!)

Hints of classical music accompany the harp, of course, like wispy clouds joyriding in an aural mashup that wafts along with strains of indie folk, “chamber folk,” avant garde, jazz, and hybrids called “baroque pop,” “freak folk” and more, all part of her singular musical soundscape(s).

Newsom also plays the harpsichord and piano, which she has put into service in settings ranging from small clubs with a rock foursome to concert halls accompanied by symphony orchestras from London to Sydney to Brooklyn.

All while tending to a voice that shifts from child-like to husky, piercing to plaintive, lilting to tremulous.

Counter-intuitively but perfectly sensible with a moment’s thought, she’s also a fan of rap because she, too, is besotted with inventive wordplay.

Two self-recorded and released albums in 2002-03 garnered Newsom enough of a near-cultish following to bring her to the attention of the Chicago-based indie label Drag City. The label remains her musical home today, offering an open canvas for her considerable flights of creative fancy that rarely if ever hew to the commercial constraints of song length, structure, and immediately accessible meanings.

Add in her less than conventional rhythms, melodies and voice timbre and we get the whole package of a fiercely independent artist dead-set on exploring her own vision for music-making that doesn’t read or sound quite like anyone else (though Joni Mitchell fans may see fit to engage that discussion).



Case in point: the song “Baby Birch” from Newsom’s 2010 album, “Have One on Me,” a three-disc set whose 18 songs clock in at an epic-length 124 minutes.

“Baby Birch” is unquestionably about mourning the loss of a baby. But that’s pretty much the only thing this nine-minute-and-thirty-second cascade of emotion and bracing imagery doesn’t leave open to question and any given listener’s interpretation, starting with the source of the songwriter’s loss.

Abortion? Miscarriage? A decision to remain childless? The failure of a relationship that left dreamt-of children unborn?

All of these can be put forward as frameworks for what might actually have happened. But with an artist such as Newsom, steeped in myth, poetry, literature and historical allusions, there’s little reason to think actuality serves as much more than a building block for all that flows through her work.

Instead, it’s the emotional terrain, wordplay and musicality that matter, the exploration of which offers up intrinsic rewards to both creator and audience that are not dependent on literal renderings.

In such free-form creativity, the road is better than the inn, the open sea superior to the harbor. Her songs consistently beg big questions but just as consistently refuse the beggar, short-circuiting our Need to Know and redirecting us (and herself) to the tensions and ramifications of deep feeling, tenuous grasps and uncertainty.


“Baby Birch” is a long and fascinating wallow in sadness and regret, some of it named and understood, some obscure and opaque. The You Tube rendering below scrolls the lyrics across the screen; feel free to go there now if you like, or pick up some more intro first.

It begins by telling us exactly what it is about:

This is the song for Baby Birch
I will never know you
And at the back of what we’ve done
There is the knowledge of you

Well I wish we could take every path
Could spend a hundred years
Adoring you
Yes, I wish we could take every path
‘Cause you know I hated to close
The door on you

“What we’ve done…” and “…close the door on you” suggests agency on part of the parents, sounding here like they’ve made a choice. But about what?

To abort? Place for adoption? Depart from each other and remain childless?

Do you remember staring
Up at the stars
So far away in their bulletproof cars?
When we heard the rushing, slow intake
Of the dark, dark water
And the engine breaks
And I said

“Staring up at stars…rushing, slow intake/Of the dark, dark water/And the engine breaks…”

Has there been an accident, a crash into a lake with a stalled engine and in-rushing waters?

No matter. The overarching (and aching) point is loss, absence, the unrealized could-have-beens.

Well mercy me. I’ll be goddamned
It’s been a long, long time
Since I last saw you
And I have never known the plan
It’s been a long, long time
How are you?

Is Baby Birch in heaven? Adopted out to another home with no contact for that “long, long time?”

What “plan?”

More possibilities abound:

Your eyes are green. Your hair is gold
Your hair is black. Your eyes are blue
I closed the ranks, and I doubled back —
But, you know I hated to close
The doggone door on you

There’s that agency again. But what was the nature of that metaphorical door?

Let’s give it a listen and reading here before some concluding comments.



The squawking of a mama goose “cussing” while protecting her eggs can be humorous when one encounters it, but just reminds the mother in this tale that she has no such privilege. And then we go darker still:

There is a blacksmith
And there is a shepherd

And there is a butcher-boy
And there is a barber, who’s cutting
And cutting away at my only joy

These ghastly images bring back the specter of abortion or miscarriage, with surgical tools “cutting away” at her “only joy.”

Newsom (a distant cousin to the California governor) is married to the comedian Andy Sammler, with whom she shares a 4-year-old daughter. Lest anyone think she cowers under her bedcovers as a brooding existentialist, she appears buoyant, engaging and accommodating in interviews and on stage, flashing a whimsical humor and unlike the narrator above, open to joy.

But that’s life, after all. The good, the bad. Melancholy and mirth.

The luxury of pondering it all, and with luck and commitment, the privilege of turning it into an exploration and expression unique to one’s self.

Though her intensely musical-minded physician parents barred her from television and radio exposure during her childhood in Nevada City, California (an hour north of Sacramento), she has since acted on television (“Portlandia”), jabbered with Letterman and Colbert, and both narrated and acted in the Paul Thomas Anderson film, “Inherent Vice.”

More importantly: 20 years in, she has constructed a body of work that bears and rewards consistent attention, which she now has in abundance from a large cohort of ardent followers and approving critics.

Few hard declarative truths in her music. Check that: none at all. That’s not, apparently, and to speak metaphorically, what she has been put on this earth to do.

But she is cool with that. Ever the resolutely inward-looking poet, she writes, with what feels paradoxically like a kind of quiet fervor, this in the short, power-packed song with which we will close below:

Our nature does not change by will
In the winter, ’round the ruined mill
The creek is lying, flat and still
It is water, though it’s frozen

To which one may feel moved to respond with absolute certainty:

Yeah yeah yeah.
Yeah yeah yeah.
With an artist like that,
We know we should be glad.



My thanks to alert reader Rebekah Felipe, who caught, early in 2024 (It’s never too late!), erroneous lyrics I had cited in the stanza from “On a Good Day,” which actually belong to a song of the same title by the English electronic music group Above and Beyond. Correct lyrics have since been changed above, with a slight change to the commentary.

Check out this blog’s public page on Facebook for 1-minute snippets of wisdom and other musings from the world’s great thinkers and artists, accompanied by lovely photography.

Deep appreciation to the photographers! Unless otherwise stated, some rights reserved under Creative Commons licensing.

Elizabeth Haslam, whose photos (except for the books) grace the rotating banner at top of page.

Library books photo by Larry Rose, all rights reserved, contact:

Newsom photos by kDamo, Dublin, Ireland

4 comments to Brilliant Songs #27: Joanna Newsom’s “Baby Birch”

  • Robert Spencer  says:

    The lyrics to “Baby Birch” do poignantly capture the dilemma women face when either abortion or adoption seems to be the only way out. I do know a woman who put her son up for adoption when she was 14 years old. Even now, so many years later, his birthdate casts a sad shadow over her. What became of him? Is he even alive? Could he live nearby? Am I grandmother? These are tough questions to face on a daily basis. As far as abortion is concerned, there are too many in this country who want to paint these women as cold-hearted, uncaring individuals who have committed murder without a shred of remorse. Some here in Texas shout out their Christianity with stickers like “Jesus loves me…why didn’t you?” It’s a shame.

    • Andrew Hidas  says:

      One of the many things this song had me thinking about was the anti-abortion arguments that try to frame women seeking abortion as some casual method of birth control, a simple “oops” that they rectify with all the consideration of getting a manicure. If this song is about abortion, which I’m not at all sure it is, Newsom sets the record straight on the deep and lasting anguish it entails.

  • Fred Dodge  says:

    I first heard Joanna Newsom on KALX, University of Berkeley ‘college’ radio. An exceptional source for music not of the mainstream. Her commanding voice style is so self-assured. Thanks for the reminder, Andrew.

    • Andrew Hidas  says:

      That reminds me of one of the tiny pleasures of road trips, Fred: plugging into college radio stations across the land, all of them seemingly cut from the same groove of non-mainstream hipness. I will have to check whether I can snag KALX streaming on the Internet, thanks!

Leave a Reply