So Much From So Little: Claire Keegan’s Novella, “Foster”

I’ve gotten to an age where I’m starting to do some basic math on how many 400-pages-and-more books I have left in me to read. Faced with one highly regarded tome of 500 pages and two others of more or less equal interest at 250 pages each, my tendency in recent years has been to go with the latter, particularly when stretching the timeframe out to the 10 or 15 or more years I might reasonably hope to live (should I be so fortunate, every new day being its own blessing).

Sure, if I choose to limit my reading most all the time to books shorter than some self-imposed limit, I will miss out on countless enriching opportunities.

But the plethora of truly remarkable literature readily available today at every page count, from every corner of the world, pairs with my guaranteed mortality to tell me I am going to miss out on countless terrific opportunities no matter the length of the books I read the rest of my life.

Can’t read ’em all, unfortunately.

That being so, my inclination is to read as many books as I can, all the more increasing the chance I will stumble across works that speak to and move me in their brilliance.

Which is how it turned out the other day with “Foster,” an 87-page novella from my new literary hero, the Irish writer Claire Keegan, whose entire career makes a shambles of my under-400-pages-per book preference with a multi-award-winning, critically lauded output of just five books totaling barely 700 pages since her 1999 debut collection of short stories.

“Foster” is not at all atypical of that output in having initially required barely one hour of my life. Nor in the fact that it said and suggested so much with so few words that it left me using a good number of the hours it saved me in its brevity flipping back through the pages to address the one overarching question among the many others it left me with: “Just how did she do that?”



Keegan seems to know exactly what she’s up to in crafting little jewels of sentences in which every word has been buffed to reveal an expansive radiance, like waves pulsing onto a night beach under the moon.

“I do think no story has ever been read properly unless it’s read twice,” she told the British newspaper “The Guardian” in an interview last September. “So it’s a longer book, you see, than you think it is, because it needs to be read twice. Double the pages.”

(Sense of humor, too…)

Her own labors on behalf of those pages are obvious throughout “Foster,” which opens with an unnamed girl of indeterminate age (my guess: 7-8) riding in a car with her father after Sunday mass.

Instead of going home where an inexactly numbered gaggle of children including another soon to hatch (Irish, Catholic) are implied to have the house bursting at the seams and their parents’ attentions to them severely wanting, the girl and her father are headed to “this place belonging to the Kinsellas.”

Claire Keegan

The girl spends the ride lying on the back seat, idly noting the sky and crafting scenarios of just who “the Kinsellas” might be and what the life she is apparently headed for there might be like.

She soon begins to find out when they greet her and her father with kindness and calm, Mrs. Kinsella kissing her upon arrival, the men exchanging pleasantries about the weather before they all go inside for a meal.

During which we get a glimpse into the character of the father and the home the girl hails from when he follows talk of thirsty crops with: “Wasn’t it a great year for weather all the same. Never saw the like of it. I nearly split my head on the rafters pitching it in.”

Then the girl: “I wonder why my father lies about the hay. He is given to lying about things that would be nice, if they were true.” 

After dinner, her father indulges his ritual smoke, stands to leave, accepts an armful of rhubarb the Mrs. cuts quickly from the yard, then walks outside to start the car and says only this, without touching his daughter upon leave-taking: “Try not to fall into the fire, you.”

She then asks us, “Why did he leave without so much as a good-bye, without even mentioning that he would come back for me?”


Keegan takes us through a young girl’s summer idyll in its remaining pages, unsure whether her father will ever return, those details, like so many others, unspoken.

Meanwhile, she learns day by day what it is to live in and for that day, their unhurried rhythms and rituals taking steady root as she blossoms under the watchful, caring eyes of this couple whose love for her is expressed in myriad, everyday ways, and whose own life together eventually reveals far more than we are privy to initially.

Besides her universally acclaimed brevity, Keegan’s other genius is in taking us into the inner perceptual world of a young girl, taking cues on her unfolding life with simple awareness, reminding us that the almost startling newness and discovery we see in infants as they take in more of the world with each blink does not turn off as that world broadens out evermore.

Reflecting near the tale’s end on her reading with Kinsella, she observes:

“At first, I struggled with some of the bigger words, but Kinsella kept his fingernail under each, patiently, until I guessed it or half-guessed it and then I did this by myself until I no longer needed to guess, and read on. It was like learning to ride the bike; I felt myself taking off, the freedom of going places I couldn’t have gone before, and it was easy.”

Indeed, most all the basic tasks of life we learn with difficulty at first become merely routine with experience, and years on, we can hardly remember or understand what it was that impeded us.

Except, perhaps, what it is to be and remain fully human and alive with the spirit of possibility and discovery underscoring our days. Strange how easily that can be dropped amidst the stresses and distractions that seep into our lives.

Fortunately, we have artists like Keegan to lead us back there, one artfully, briefly sketched word and scene at a time, leaving us plentiful additional time to mull their implications.


A minimally abridged 2010 version of “Foster” in The New Yorker should be available and enjoyable to read here. Better yet, buy five copies of the full-length American edition printed last year, spread the wealth and give at least four away as Christmas presents. Beats a fruit cake any day of the week, and will last at least as long…



Comments? Questions? Suggestions, Objections, Attaboys? Just scroll on down to the Comments section below. No minimum or maximum word counts!

Check out this blog’s public page on Facebook for 1-minute snippets of wisdom and other musings from the world’s great thinkers and artists, accompanied by lovely photography.

Deep appreciation to the photographers! Unless otherwise stated, some rights reserved under Creative Commons licensing.

Elizabeth Haslam, whose photos (except for the books) grace the rotating banner at top of page.

Library books photo by Larry Rose, all rights reserved, contact:

Reader by Kyle Wang, Seattle, Washington

Beach by Kevin, Ramona, California


11 comments to So Much From So Little: Claire Keegan’s Novella, “Foster”

  • Jay Helman  says:

    Well, my friend, this post represents a nudge that I was vaguely aware I needed. My self-imposed reading rule since retirement several years ago is that reading any book of fiction must be followed by reading a non-fiction work. It recently occurred to me that the length of both the fiction and non-fiction books are accompanied by a shockingly and increasingly furious passage of time, leaving me to ponder what all I am missing as the days and years race by. Age 73 is coming in a few weeks and I, unlike you, have not bothered to consider the math involved in years/books-not-yet-read. No longer. As of this reading of your post I shall begin looking into the novella,and will begin with Claire Keegan. Many thanks for the nudge.

    • Andrew Hidas  says:

      Hadn’t thought of that particular rhythm—fiction to nonfiction in a kind of tag team sing-song—but you’re right, Jay, the nice rational beat of that goes awry when nonfiction in particular falls prey to the modern penchant for throwing in every last detail of every damn sneeze from every damn character in every damn meeting in a 900-page opus whose subtext, if not blatant title, is “The History of Everything.”

      Funny detail of my own: this post was partly inspired by my evolving math around the Books Remaining To Be Read rubric, partly by the brilliance of the Keegan novella and her approach to literature, and partly by espying a blurb for the recently released 992-page Barbra Streisand biography that weighs in at 3.12 pounds. News of which mostly caused me to put my head in my hands and dread the prospect of what will surely beget Taylor Swift’s forthcoming 6,890-page life-till-now memoir sometime before the end of the decade. All this while all of our reading habits are said to be going down the toilet in our constantly pinged, attention deficit age. What’s up with all that, Bro??

      • Jay Helman  says:

        My thought is that we stay away from epic celebrity bios, and focus on pieces of substance. Pardon my use of this blog to urge folks to read Rachel Maddow book, Prequel. It is brilliant, riveting, and provides much to learn about how we got here with open and rampant anti-semitism and fascism in our country.

  • David Jolly  says:

    Oh, Andrew (and friends), do you have a treat in store for you: Claire Keegan’s Small Things Like These. Another gem, a Christmas story no less (but without a trace of Hallmark maudlin or cheeriness), rightly touted as “a deeply affecting story of hope, quiet heroism, and empathy.” And now, as you have informed me Ms. Keegan directs us, I will read it again.

    • Andrew Hidas  says:

      Just found that hour, David (well, it was a little bit more; had to break for a late night snack), but you were, per usual, spot-on in your assessment of this true masterpiece of a fine and haunting story, well-told. (“Exquisitely” told, actually, but I’m disinclined to superlatives in this instance, given how much mileage Ms. Keegan herself gets out of stark observations and everyday words.)

      Given the hour, I’ll have to regrettably pass on an immediate re-read, but that just leaves all the more anticipatory pleasure for another day.

  • Robert Spencer  says:

    I’ll echo a similar remark from both Jay and David: I’m going to read “Foster”, and the number of pages in books today are keeping pace with technology involved in writing now. Word processing may be the culprit. Where have Royals and white out gone? Perhaps I’m just too darn old. “The Great Gatsby” is about 200 pages. “The Christmas Carol” even less. Call me Ishmael!

  • Robert Spencer  says:

    Maybe Ismael isn’t the best example!

  • Andrew Hidas  says:

    Yeah, David, was hard to avoid multiple glowing references to “Small Things…” in my research here, and it’s definitely on my future reading list. At 700 pages for her entire oeuvre, I think I may perform the rare feat of reading a noted author’s entire collected works. (Lucky for me in that regard that she is a painfully slow, deliberate writer.) I had fun comparing her New Yorker abridged version of “Foster” to the full text. Only minimal and subtle enhancements in the full text, could see her tinkering around the edges of various sentences, along with an occasional brief scene that was left out of the abridged version altogether. A fine read, in either case, though—a lot of meat on those good bones!

    Interesting and new idea (for me), Robert, that word processing may be the culprit in length-creep. My gut tells me you’re onto something. I still remember all too vividly screwing something up so badly on a manuscript page back in the day that not only did I have to rip it out of my typewriter and start all over, but it also affected the previous or subsequent pages, so I’d have three pages to retype (in a serious huff, given my hunt & peck technique). I remember one moment reaching the end of my rope with that sordid business, when I had to literally restrain myself from a sudden overwhelming nervous system urge to heave my typewriter right through my large picture window next to me. Beat the impulse down with a major imposition of will, but just barely…

    Now, it’s highlight with command-A, copy with command-C, insert with command-V. No wonder my blog posts tend to be longer than my essays & editorials of old! :-)

  • Deanna  says:

    I’ve gotten to the point where I just need a break from mass murder, rape, child abduction and other evils. I know some kind of conflict is necessary to drive fiction, but does it always have to be extreme? It sounds like Claire Keegan is just the kind of writer I’m looking for.

  • Robert Spencer  says:

    Let me edit my first post. Woops…all I have is white out.

  • Andrew Hidas  says:

    Deanna, I’ve noted the past several years a visceral, physical revulsion I feel in my gut to depictions of extreme violence. Not sure whether the squeamishness is just a matter of age or some cumulative battering that has finally overloaded my system, but suffice to say I hear & identify with you loud & clear.

    Robert, you inspired me to investigate whether white-out even exists anymore or went the way of the horse & buggy. So I was surprised to see it is alive (though I’m guessing not all that well-nor-in-demand), just $1.59 at Target. Would be interesting to survey both its manufacturers and buyers, to confirm it’s been in the death spiral I would assume it has been in and leading to only one end, along with their guesses as to when that end might be.

Leave a Reply